REVIEW: One Day in December by Josie Silver

One Day in December

A huge thank you to Crown Publishing for the Advanced Copy via Netgalley!

I found out about this book while I was scrolling through NetGalley. The book reminded me of a mix of Love, Rosie and One Day. As you may have noticed, I am a sucker for anything in the romantic genre. I’ll be honest, going into the book, I thought I had the plot figured out. Often, books in this genre are on the predictable side. Instead, I found One Day in December was a well executed, genre defying, just plain-old-good book.

I love Laurie. She is imperfect, but she tries her best in all areas of her life. What I really love about her is her level of self-reflection and the value she puts on her relationship with Sarah. Laurie spent the better part of a year pining and obsessing over the man she saw at a bus stop and when he resurfaced as Sarah’s new boyfriend, she didn’t do the predictable thing and try to steal him away. Instead, she did the realistic thing and repressed the hell out of her feelings and valued her friendship with Sarah above everything else. Throughout the book the focus of the book wasn’t only on the one between Jack and Laurie, but also on the one between Laurie and Sarah. The amount of development of the secondary characters was spectacular, something that is rare in this genre.
One Day in December is told from the point of view of both Jack and Laurie. Reading their story from both points of view really added to the depth of it all. You see them both struggle to balance their initial attraction with their precarious situation with Jack as Sarah’s boyfriend. Without going into too many details, you get to see both Jack and Laurie try to suppress their chemistry and do the right thing by Laurie and the rest of the people in their lives. It’s complex, it’s authentic, and it’s well done will-they-won’t-they story.

I really can’t recommend One Day in December highly enough. The characters were deep and complex and real. There were emotional and real consequences for their actions. I delighted in watching them grow and evolve as people throughout the years the book follows them. The plot rarely dragged. This book was a delight cover to cover and I can’t wait to read more of Josie Silver’s books.

You may also like


  1. I am a sucker for YA books even though perhaps I should stick to the challenging literature actually written for a 30-year-old…but a good story is a good story! And I love any tale told from multiple perspectives.

  2. It does my heart a lot of good to see that there are still readers I the world and I’m not the only one. I loved this blog necajse it was a good read, it gave me an book idea to read, and it also gave me ideas on how to break down books that I have read as a review on my own blog without giving away to much information about said book. Something I have always wanted to do.

    Great Read…😊

  3. Love the way you made this picture! I always wonder about what kind of pictures to make when I read an ebook instead of a physical copy and this is a great way to do it! Also the way you describe this book makes it sound like a book I might try 🙂

  4. Lovely review, although it might not seem like a book I would read and love, I’m sure I’ll catch it when it becomes a movie, because with the right cast it can be an adorable movie <3

  5. Sounds like a really good book. I enjoyed your review and it makes me want to read the book

Leave a Reply